The 9th US Circuit Court of Appeals has upheld the Constitutionality of the phrase “under God” in the Pledge of Allegiance and the motto “In God We Trust” on American currency. This double body-blow denies two lawsuits spearheaded by Michael Newdow. You can read the Court’s opinions here and here.
I have not had time to absorb these rulings in detail, but right away I wonder how the Court can use the Declaration of Independence (citing the phrase “endowed by their Creator” as an expression of the Founding Fathers’ beliefs) as a litmus test for the Constitutionality of the phrase “under God.” The DoI is an historically significant document, but it has no force of law whatsoever. The Constitution does, and it’s internally consistent throughout that government and religion ought not mix.
The Court also makes confounding statements like “the motto (’In God We Trust’) has no theological or ritualistic impact. As stated by the Congressional report, it has ’spiritual and psychological value’ and ‘inspirational quality.’” Please explain to me the substantive difference between “theological” and “spiritual”–for that matter, how can the word “God” itself be said to have no theological impact???
Margaret Downey (former president of Atheist Alliance International, now a “freethought free agent”) announces the formation of the Unity 2013 Event Committee. What is Unity 2013? Nobody knows just yet, but what we do know is that it’ll be big, it has the blessing of such notables as Daniel Dennett, and it’ll involve many (if not most) of the major freethought-friendly organizations. To keep abreast of the details as they unfold, check out the


Earthquake-devastated Haiti has become a magnet for kooky, misguided (but perhaps well-intentioned) religious groups. Scientologist John Travolta (disguised, apparently, as L. Ron Hubbard–see photo at right)
Podcast #82 – Creation
Friday, February 26th, 2010Thanks to the many fellow science fans who joined us for the Creation screening at Atlanta’s Landmark Midtown Art Cinema. And thanks to Royal Orchid Thai Cuisine for accommodating our unexpected horde.
Tags: annie's box, charles darwin, creation, david mcallister, evolution, jason bourque, jennifer connelly, paul bettany
Posted in atheism, books, buddhism, commentary, evolution, movies, news, podcast, religion, science | 5 Comments »